Rocky Coastal Inlet with Battle Ship
Object type | Painting |
Genre | Landscape |
Date | ca. 1592 |
Dimensions | 15 x 19.4 cm |
Support | Copper |
Medium | Oil |
Our attribution | Jan Brueghel the Elder |
Other authorities | Ertz 2008-10, #100 Ertz 1979, #1 |
Location/Most Recent Sale | Germany, Private Collection |
Tags | Birds, Coast, Rocks, Fishermen, Merchants, Boat |
3 copies/variants: one Koetser 1966 (panel 14 x 19.3, ill. Essen 1997 p.131 fig.2); second Indianapolis, Museum of Art (copper 10.2 x 11.4)--exhibited Essen 1997. Third variant sold London (Christie's 13.xii.91 # 177 as circle of JBI), copper, 14.6 x 17.8. There are photos of these in RKD voorordening, and all 4 are exhibited in Russell article. A more distant version (?) is illustrated Essen 1997, p.131, fig.3. Curious that even Jan's very earliest painting seems to exist in such a lot of copies and variants.
Another distant but very curious variant sold Sotheby's London 3 December 2008, #8 (panel, 15.5 x 18). To harbor have been added all these figures from just slightly later JB works, like Ertz 13 from 1595--a figure group is directly reproduced from there. Since Ertz 13 was in the Barberini Collection and hence didn't leave Italy before 20th century, that would mean that either the painter of the Sotheby's picture worked from a drawing by JB, or knew the painting in Rome. But other figures here, especially woman seated on basket at far left and figures in midground with cart, are I am sure taken from works from school of Beuckelaer, works like Getty picture in fact. So this is a very peculiar pastiche. Also a tiny painting, same size as Ertz 1, but on panel.